#GivingTuesday | Should your nonprofit bother?

November 24, 2013

Earlier this year, I stumbled upon a nonprofit organization via Facebook, and impulsively became a $10 a month donor. The mission had a strong personal connection for me, and I’m a big believer in the power of monthly giving.

Nothing happened.

No instant thank you via email following my donation, no thank you letter. Weeks passed. No nothing. Now it’s six months later and my credit card is still dinged every month, yet I’ve yet to receive any acknowledgement from the organization or word on how my gift is changing lives.

I’d love to report that this represents an isolated incident.

Unfortunately it’s been my experience I’d guestimate over 60% of the time.

You might be asking “What do your personal experiences have to do with GivingTuesday?” Just this: the very act of making a charitable gift IS, indeed, very personal.

Why do your donors give?

It seems to me that many nonprofit organizations are lacking the basic fundamentals and can’t answer this question that lies at the very heart of your fundraising and communications efforts. The last time I asked a client this question he said that their organization had a mission that every American would support. Um, no. You don’t.

The struggles facing nonprofit organizations today are much of their own making. We’re failing to pay attention to why our donors give, we’re failing to pay attention to the donors we have — and as a result we’re simply losing donors at a faster rate than we are acquiring them.

There are those who think that “donor-centered fundraising” is just another buzz word in the nonprofit world. It’s not. I would venture to say that donor-centered fundraising is the healthiest – I would go so far as to say most honest – method to long-term, sustainable funding. It’s the very reason the 2013 BETA testing of my membership program began with the not-so-sexy topic of selecting your organization’s donor database…rather than Fundraising on Facebook.

There are more diversions facing nonprofits than ever before.

Good God.  You know it and I know it.  And then along comes #GivingTuesday. Straight from the GivingTuesday site: “ a movement to create a national day of giving to kick off the giving season added to the calendar on the Tuesday following Thanksgiving, Black Friday and Cyber Monday. The second annual GivingTuesday is on December 3, 2013. In the same way that retail stores take part in Black Friday, we want the giving community to come together for #GivingTuesday. We ask that partners create and commit to a project for/on #GivingTuesday and then help spread the word to their networks.”

In his post, Why Your Non-Profit Should Avoid #GivingTuesday Like the Plague, my friend Joe Garecht argues that #GivingTuesday encourages spot giving, and your organization isn’t likely to raise much.

Joe notes that “Aside from the problem of cutting through the clutter, the truth is that social media is a terrible fundraising medium.  Most people do NOT click donate now because of a social media post.”

And he makes some very good points.

Yet I also agree with my friend, John Haydon, who agrees to an extent and says:

“I’ll be the first to agree that social media stinks for fundraising – if you define fundraising as donations. Email converts much better than social media, and of course face-to-face converts best! That said, social media is about listening to and connecting with your community, which are critical parts of any fundraising relationship.

#GivingTuesday is a chance for nonprofits to learn how to integrate social, email, and other channels in a well-planned campaign. I think many of your points are important considerations for nonprofits, but not deal-killers in their #GivingTuesday participation.” (emphasis mine)

I also agree with Claire Axelrad who commented: “What I DO like using #GivingTuesday for is gratitude. And for this purpose it comes at a perfect time of year. The easiest thing for resource-strapped nonprofits to do is to send a thank you video –something super simple created on a smart phone and sent out via email or whatever social channels their supporters frequent — simply thanking folks for all their giving throughout the year.

Using #GivingTuesday for stewardship, rather than solicitation, gets around many of Joe’s objections that it results in ‘spot giving,’ perhaps cannibalizing other fundraising efforts.”

Amen, Claire.

Would I tell you to avoid #GivingTuesday? Not necessarily.   Here’s the deal:  Before you decide if #GivingTuesday is right for your organization, ask yourself:

  1. Does my organization have the back end systems in place to acknowledge and thank new donors promptly?
  2. How often and how effectively are we communicating with the donors we already have throughout the year?
  3. Can we use #GivingTuesday in a way that brings us closer to our donors?  If so, how (Claire has answered that one nicely)?

Your overriding focus should always be on providing exemplary donor care.  Every *opportunity,* should be approached from the perspective of “what’s in it for my donors?

{ 5 comments… read them below or add one }

Karen November 24, 2013 at 5:45 pm

Giving Tuesday is a joke. We have Black Friday, Small Business Saturday, Cyber Monday, and now Giving Tuesday. By lumping philanthropy in with a weekend of shopping, we will get the same thing the retailers get – a lot of impulse purchases. If your nonprofit is looking for a quick infusion of cash, that will cost you money down the road (in lost donors), then Giving Tuesday is for you. If you think philanthropy is more than shopping for the latest deal and donors are more valuable than shoppers, then don’t waste your time with Giving Tuesday (unless you use it as a thank you, as you and Claire suggested).

Sadly, the nonprofits that jump on the Giving Tuesday bandwagon and invest way more time in this than they should are the smallest ones that cannot afford to get distracted.

Pamela Grow November 24, 2013 at 7:49 pm

I like the idea of using #GivingTuesday for stewarding our donors. And, hey, I’d love to see Donor Appreciation Day — or even a week dedicated to our donors.

Sylvie Labrosse November 20, 2014 at 10:21 am

yes, yes and yes! you’re bang on here. Non profits need to look at their overall strategies and consider whether or not these reactive activities like #givingtuesday or another of my “favourites”, the voting to get a donation scheemes… is really worth their efforts. To many are looking at these things as a way to raise funds when the fact is if they aren’t already building relationships with their donors – they have bigger problems. Just because “all the cool kids” are doing it, doesn’t mean you have to jump on board.

Megan Hutchison November 12, 2015 at 10:38 am

We are a volunteer heavy organization, so we’re going to use it to promote a volunteer workday and in-kind gifts. We’ll see how it goes!

Pamela Grow November 12, 2015 at 6:13 pm

Love it, Megan! Let me know how it goes.

Leave a Comment

{ 11 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: